Coronado Island Real Estate

Coronado Market Analysis


  Quarterly-Report.gif

 

Coronado Market Analysis

"The Transition Period"

 

Quarterly-Report1.gif

  There were three deals closed in the "by the beach" zone this quarter, and we are proud to say Owen Properties handled all three (and have a fourth in escrow!).  Each of these transactions had a common theme: The seller dropped price and looked like a "deal" relative to competitive listings; the deal pricing generated buyer interest; the buyer submitted a "low ball" offer; the seller countered to bring the buyer closer to the list price; the transaction closed.
 


This theme has implications for buyers and sellers who must understand "bargain" deals are becoming the comps.  If you are a buyer, strike now and insist on 2009 pricing.  A village condo that sold in 2006 for $1 million now costs $750,000.    
 
If you are a seller, determine whether you need to sell in the next 12 months.  If so, cut a deal and move on without incurring additional holding costs or market risk.  If you are a seller and have longer holding power, consider the implications of liquidity returning.  Borrowers in Coronado can now obtain up to 96% financing on loans up to $700,000, and up to 80% financing on loans up to $1.5 million.  That is a major change relative to where we were three months ago.  Liquidity trouble--exasperated by market fear--caused our inventory pile up and sale price drops.  We are in a transition period now.  Liquidity returning and fear departing will lead to stable prices followed by rising prices, but it will take time to clear the existing oversupply of homes.
 
The trends described above are reflected in the tables.  Transaction volume in Coronado in the first quarter accelerated relative to 2008 because loans were easier for buyers to obtain and a segment of sellers became realistic about pricing.  Prices dropped year over year.

SOLD PRICE (PER SQUARE FOOT) : Q1 2008 VERSUS Q1 2009 

   Q1 2008
 Q1 2009
 Change
 92118  $911.15  $663.67  -27%
 Village Homes
 $857.36  $719.67  -16%
 Village Condos
 $852.60
 $615.04  -28%
 Shores  $1,069.52  $1,156.48   8%
 Cays Detached  $807.50  $400.67  -50%
 Cays Condos
 $662.21  $485.51  -27%

 

AVERAGE SALES PRICE: Q1 2008 VERSUS Q1 2009

  Q1 2008
 Q1 2009
 Change
92118
 $1,430,109 $1,193,800  -17%
 Village Homes
 $1,516,875 $1,467,600
 -3%
 Village Condos
 $1,189,000 $930,250
 -22%
 Shores  $1,567,500 $1,246,333
 -20%
 Cays Detached
 $1,615,000 $858,333
 -47%
 Cays Condos
 $1,112,500 $753,000
 -32%

 

DEL BEACH VILLAGE: Q1 2008 VERSUS Q1 2009

No Activity in Q1 2008 or Q1 2009


NUMBER OF SALES: Q1 2008 VERSUS Q1 2009
  Q1 2008
 Q1 2009
Change
 92118  23  30
 30%
 Village Homes
 8  15  88%
 Village Condos  5  4  -20%
 Shores  7  3  -57%
 Cays Detached  1  3  200%
 Cays Condos
 2  5  150%

 

DAYS ON MARKET: Q1 2008 VERSUS Q1 2009  

 

   Q1 2008
 Q1 2009
 Change
 92118  111  152
 37%
 Village Homes
 89  155  74%
 Village Condos
 164  205  25%
 Shores  122  82  -33%
 Cays Detached
 54  120  122%
 Cays Condos
 53  162  206%

 

BY THE BEACH: Homes/Condos from 10th St. to Ocean Blvd.

   Q1 2008
 Q1 2009
 Change
 Sold Listings
 1
3
 200%
 SP  $2,000,000
$1,872,000
 -6%
 SP/Sqft  $1,013.68  $742.47  -27%
 DOM  400  225  -44%

 

Have a Question or Comment?
 
email: tom@owenproperties.com
 
phone: 619.972.6936
   
Your home is a high priced asset that warrants professional representation.  We at Owen Properties have over a billion dollars in transaction experience and degrees from UCLA, UCLA Anderson School of Business (MBA), Berkeley and UCLA's School of Law (JD).  We also have experience writing speeches for the President of the United States and conducting internet marketing campaigns for hundred million dollar companies.  As marketers, attorneys, brokers and deal makers, we would be proud to assist you.

 

  ______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Annual-Report.gif

Coronado Annual Report: 2008

"Statistics & Analysis"

Highlights

  • Del Beach Village was the winner in 2008
  • Buyers went bargain hunting in 2008
  • Transaction volume in Coronado was down 39% in 2008 relative to 2007
  • Inventory will be high in 2009

2008 Performance...and what lies ahead

As 2008 comes to an end (thankfully!), we thought you would appreciate seeing how Coronado real estate fared.

 The Del’s Beach Village was the top performer in Coronado, and the areas near the beach held up well.  Condos did okay, but the numbers are somewhat inflated by the four strong Beach Village sales (two of which Owen Properties handled!). 

We read an article recently on retail sales, and an expert commented, “We are all bargain hunters now.”  That is how it felt for Owen Properties in 2008.  Generally, if a seller wanted buyer attention, the seller’s property had to appear to be a bargain.  Once the property was perceived as a bargain, buyers would come along with interest and offers but would request an additional 10 to 20 percent off the bargain price so as to insulate themselves from further market drops.

Coronado sellers were reluctant to price themselves as bargains, and especially reluctant to give discounts thereafter.  This difference in opinion amongst buyers and sellers led to a massive drop in transaction volume.  Overall, Coronado volume was down 39% in 2008 relative to 2007. 

So 2008 was a pricing tug-of-war between buyers and sellers.  It has been our experience that tug-of-war doesn’t end with both sides dropping the rope and shaking hands.  We are betting on buyers to win in 2009 because the current inventory level is high, there is unaccounted supply in the form of sellers who are waiting for the spring/summer to list, and the economy is still stumbling.  The wild card is liquidity – if interest rates stay low and down payment requirements loosen for jumbo loans, the balance could begin to shift in favor of sellers.  While we project a buyer victory in 2009, we believe it will be modest.  Historically, Coronado prices have not declined much because Coronado sellers generally have the ability to wait out bad times, as the 2008 slow sale numbers show.  This trend should continue in 2009, as it did for several years in the early 1990’s.

 

Our 2009 recommendations are as follows:

If you are a buyer in 2009, make sure you get a good price but do not insist on too much of a discount or you are likely to waste your time and miss out.  Coronado sellers are not desperate and know their real estate is in short supply. 

Also, enjoy your new Coronado home.  Real estate isn’t just about making money.  It is where you live and spend most of your time with your friends and family.  The prices you get in 2009 should be lower, and perhaps the lowest you will ever get.  Enjoy the leverage while you have it.

 If you are a seller in 2009, ask yourself whether you are one of the lucky ones – a person who owns a property unique enough that buyers will pay a reasonable price, as opposed to a bargain price, even in hard times.  That is what Beach Village owners had in 2008.  They own one of only 35 properties, a very unique product, and commanded higher prices while the rest of the world of investments – oil, stock, real estate – fell. (View at www.DelVillage.com.)

If you are a 2009 seller and do not fit into the “very unique” category – for example, if you own a standard Coronado long, tall narrow home – you particularly need to price low to attract attention, and then be prepared to further discount to make the sale.

Or, you can wait until the market shifts.  It will shift.  The question is when.  Here are the Coronado numbers for 2008 (through December 17) relative to 2007:

 

Sold Price (per square foot): 2007 versus 2008 

 

   2007  2008  Change
 92118  $896.25  $878.75  -2%
 Village Homes  $899.17  $813.02  -10%
 Village Condos  $862.30  $927.32  8%
 Shores  $1,108.07 $1,158.43
 5%
 Cays Detached
 $586.01  $547.33  -7%
 Cays Condos  $606.14 $540.86
 -11%

 

Number of Sales: 2007 versus 2008

  2007  2008  Change
92118
 270  164  -39%
Village Homes
 137  76  -45%
Village Condos
 45  28  -38%
Shores
 49  38  -22%
Cays Detached
 22  17  -23%
Cays Condos
 17  5  -71

 

 
Days on Market: 2007 versus 2008
  2007 2008
 Change
 92118 102
102
0%
Village Homes 79
82
 4%
Village Condos
 98  105  7%
Shores  119  66 -45%
Cays Detached
 141  198 40%
Cays Condos  119  85 -29%
 
 
 
Del Beach Village: 2007 versus 2008
 
Listing Purchase 2007
Resale 2008  Change
Cottage 1
 $4,452,000 $5,500,000
 24%
Villa 11
 $2,415,000 $2,600,000  8$
Villa 21
 $2,500,000 $2,750,000
 10%
Villa 22
 $2,500,000 $2,680,000
 7%
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
By the Beach: Homes from 10th Street to Ocean Blvd.
 

Sold Listings
SP
SP/Sqft
 DOM
 2007  25 $2,867,449
 $1,083.74  77
 2008  13  $3,094,692  $1,090.33  103
 Change  -48%  8%  1%  34%
 
 
 
Have a Question or Comment?
 
email: tom@owenproperties.com
 
phone: 619.972.6936
   
Your home is a high priced asset that warrants professional representation.  We at Owen Properties have over a billion dollars in transaction experience and degrees from UCLA, UCLA Anderson School of Business (MBA), Berkeley and UCLA's School of Law (JD).  We also have experience writing speeches for the President of the United States and conducting internet marketing campaigns for hundred million dollar companies.  As marketers, attorneys, brokers and deal makers, we would be proud to assist you.


Tom Owen